Smithton Liquor, Smithton, IL Retailer Review

Smithton Liquor (Reviewed 6/11/2020)
     408 N Main St, Smithton, IL 62285
     618-416-8077
     Website - N/A
     Distributor Delivery Day - Unknown
     Prices - 6
     Selection - 8
     Friendliness - 8
     Helpfulness - 7
     Bourbon Knowledge - 6
     Overall Experience - 6

Recommendation – This location is a huge store with an excellent selection. Their prices are a bit high on some bottles, but given how remote it is I think it is understandable, especially given the distance anyone would need to travel for the selection they offer.

  • Basil Hayden’s Kentucky Straight Bourbon – $44 (Fair Price – $32)
  • Benchmark Old No. 8 – $13 (Fair Price – $10)
  • Bulleit Kentucky Straight Bourbon – $33 (Fair Price – $26)
  • Elijah Craig Small Batch – $30 (Fair Price – $30)
  • Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond – $20 (Fair Price – $16)
  • Old Ezra 7 Year Old – $50 (Fair Price – $50)
  • Four Roses Bourbon – $22 (Fair Price – $20)
  • Four Roses Small Batch – $38 (Fair Price – $33)
  • Knob Creek 9 Year Bourbon – Unavailable (Fair Price – $35)
  • Maker’s Mark 46 – $39 (Fair Price – $30)
  • Michter’s US 1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon – $46 (Fair Price – $45)
  • Old Forester 1920 – Unavailable (Fair Price – $60)
  • Russell’s Reserve Straight Bourbon 10 Year – $35 (Fair Price – $35)
  • Wild Turkey 101 – $18 (Fair Price – $20)
  • Woodford Reserve Straight Bourbon – $39 (Fair Price – $33)

Noteworthy Bottles:

  • Four Roses Single Barrel – $45 (Fair Price – $43)
  • E.H. Taylor Small Batch – $52 (Fair Price – $49)

Author: stlbourbonbuyers

Father, bourbon enthusiast, husband.

Leave a Reply